IPcentral Weblog
  The DACA Blog

Monday, August 23, 2010

Crovitz on the Great Internet Optimist vs. Pessimist Debate
(previous | next)

I've noted here before that Gordon Crovitz is my favorite technology policy columnist and that everything he pens for his "Information Age" column for The Wall Street Journal is well worth reading. His latest might be his best ever. It touches upon the great debate between Internet optimists and pessimists regarding the impact of digital technology on our culture and economy. His title is just perfect: "Is Technology Good or Bad? Yes." His point is that you can find evidence that technological change has both beneficial and detrimental impacts, and plenty of people on both sides of the debate to cite it for you.

He specifically references the leading pessimist, Nicholas Carr, and optimist, Clay Shirky, of our time. In The Shallows: What the Internet is Doing to Our Brains and The Big Switch: Rewiring the World, From Edison to Google, Carr paints a dismal portrait of what the Internet is doing us and the world around us. Clay Shirky responds in books like Here Comes Everybody and Cognitive Surplus: Creativity and Generosity in the a Connected Age, arguing that we are much better off because of the rise of the Net and digital technology.

This is a subject I've spent a lot of time noodling over here through the years and, most recently, I compiled all my random thoughts into a mega-post asking, "Are You an Internet Optimist or Pessimist?" That post tracks all the leading texts on both sides of this debate. I was tickled, therefore, when Gordon contacted me and asked for comment for his story after seeing my piece. [See, people really do still read blogs!]

I told Gordon that I label my own position "pragmatic optimism," which I summarized as follows: "The Internet and digital technologies are reshaping our culture, economy and society in most ways for the better, but not without some serious heartburn along the way." My bottom line comes down to a simple cost-benefit analysis: "Were we really better off in the scarcity era when we were collectively suffering from information poverty? I'll take information overload over information poverty any day."

Moreover, practically speaking, I don't see any realistic way to roll back the clock to some supposed "good 'ol days"--whenever those were. As Gordon argues, "Whatever the mix of good and bad, technology only advances and cannot be put back in the bottle." Exactly right. Thus, we need to learn to assimilate new technologies into our lives, culture, and economy. Luckily, adaptation is something that we humans are very good at. Past experience tells us that we got through previous gut-wrenching technological / social revolutions; we can get through this one, too. But, again, there will be rough patches and legitimate issues that need to be addressed as we make this journey.

So, make sure to check out Gordon's article. It's a terrifically interesting topic, and one that I still hope to turn into a book as I noted here before.

P.S. Here are a couple of other interesting essays on this topic that that have been released recently:

posted by Adam Thierer @ 10:35 AM | Books & Book Reviews , Philosophy / Cyber-Libertarianism

Share |

Link to this Entry | Printer-Friendly | Email a Comment | Post a Comment(6)


It's the best time to make some plans for the future and it is time to be happy. I have read this post and if I could I wish to suggest you few interesting things or suggestions. Maybe you could write next articles referring to this article. I desire to read even more things about it!

Posted by: test1 at March 17, 2013 5:04 PM

Wow, fantastic blog layout! How long have you been blogging for?
you make blogging look easy. The overall look of your site is excellent, let alone the content!

Posted by: null at May 2, 2013 4:26 AM

are Louis Louis Vuitton Outlet Rome

Posted by: Authentic LV Outlet Handbags at May 18, 2013 9:44 AM

Everett down,: Cothrum also addressed floodplain concerns. of course,Anyone with information is encouraged to call Trey Bounds at (214) 883-4600 or Dallas Animal Services at 311.‚ÄĚKarel Holloway is a Terrell freelance writer. from its side.despite the White House intern scandal, pneumonia, that Grupo Haddad decided to ramp up its U. a rare instance of regulators enforcing the foreign corrupt government practices act.In other filings would have to drink 17 standard size drinks to reach that blood alcohol content. He first claimed to be a felon.

Posted by: Short de foot 2013 2014 at July 9, 2014 4:40 AM

"Given the stakes, the president will now extend food and medical supplies to the Syrian opposition, including the Supreme Military Council," Kerry said Thursday.

Posted by: Nike Roshe Run FB at July 23, 2014 12:27 PM

Photo credit: ESA/CNES/Arianespace - Photo Optique Video du CSG - S. Martin

Posted by: Giubbotti Peuterey Tempesta Yd grigio scuro it at November 5, 2014 5:02 PM

Post a Comment:

Blog Main
RSS Feed  
Recent Posts
  EFF-PFF Amicus Brief in Schwarzenegger v. EMA Supreme Court Videogame Violence Case
New OECD Study Finds That Improved IPR Protections Benefit Developing Countries
Hubris, Cowardice, File-sharing, and TechDirt
iPhones, DRM, and Doom-Mongers
"Rogue Archivist" Carl Malamud On How to Fix Gov2.0
Coping with Information Overload: Thoughts on Hamlet's BlackBerry by William Powers
How Many Times Has Michael "Dr. Doom" Copps Forecast an Internet Apocalypse?
Google / Verizon Proposal May Be Important Compromise, But Regulatory Trajectory Concerns Many
Two Schools of Internet Pessimism
GAO: Wireless Prices Plummeting; Public Knowledge: We Must Regulate!
Archives by Month
  September 2010
August 2010
July 2010
June 2010
  - (see all)
Archives by Topic
  - A La Carte
- Add category
- Advertising & Marketing
- Antitrust & Competition Policy
- Appleplectics
- Books & Book Reviews
- Broadband
- Cable
- Campaign Finance Law
- Capitalism
- Capitol Hill
- China
- Commons
- Communications
- Copyright
- Cutting the Video Cord
- Cyber-Security
- Digital Americas
- Digital Europe
- Digital Europe 2006
- Digital TV
- E-commerce
- e-Government & Transparency
- Economics
- Education
- Electricity
- Energy
- Events
- Exaflood
- Free Speech
- Gambling
- General
- Generic Rant
- Global Innovation
- Googlephobia
- Googlephobia
- Human Capital
- Innovation
- Intermediary Deputization & Section 230
- Internet
- Internet Governance
- Internet TV
- Interoperability
- IP
- Local Franchising
- Mass Media
- Media Regulation
- Monetary Policy
- Municipal Ownership
- Net Neutrality
- Neutrality
- Non-PFF Podcasts
- Ongoing Series
- Online Safety & Parental Controls
- Open Source
- PFF Podcasts
- Philosophy / Cyber-Libertarianism
- Privacy
- Privacy Solutions
- Regulation
- Search
- Security
- Software
- Space
- Spectrum
- Sports
- State Policy
- Supreme Court
- Taxes
- The FCC
- The FTC
- The News Frontier
- Think Tanks
- Trade
- Trademark
- Universal Service
- Video Games & Virtual Worlds
- VoIP
- What We're Reading
- Wireless
- Wireline
Archives by Author
PFF Blogosphere Archives
We welcome comments by email - look for a link to the author's email address in the byline of each post. Please let us know if we may publish your remarks.

The Progress & Freedom Foundation